Ripple’s $125M XRP Fine Stands as Court Rejects SEC Deal Attempt
By: tronweekly|2025/05/16 15:00:13
0
Share
Key Takeaways:Judge Torres rejected Ripple and the SEC’s joint bid to dissolve the XRP sales injunction.The court ruled that their settlement request failed to meet procedural requirements under Rule 60.Ripple and the SEC are still aligned to resolve the case through a revised joint motion.In a dramatic development in the long-running SEC vs. Ripple lawsuit, Judge Analisa Torres denied a joint motion by Ripple Labs and the Securities and Exchange Commission seeking a path to settlement.The motion sought to lift the injunction in place that prohibited institutional XRP sales by Ripple and reduce the civil fine from $125 million to $50 million. The judge, however, did not grant the request, deeming it “procedurally improper.”#XRPCommunity #SECGov v. #Ripple #XRP Judge Torres has denied the parties’ motion for an indicative ruling. “If jurisdiction were restored to this Court, the Court would deny the parties’ motion as procedurally improper.” pic.twitter.com/4s95ILvzsy— James K. Filan (@FilanLaw) May 15, 2025The crux of the matter is that of the procedural mechanism utilized. Parties had invoked the provision of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 62.1, by means of which a district court is permitted to make a non-binding indicative ruling in cases in which its jurisdiction is restricted on account of an active appeal.Judge Torres ruled that even assuming jurisdiction was revived, she would have rejected the motion, noting that the parties had not achieved the required legal burden for this relief.Legal Oversight in Motion Draws ScrutinyThe motion, submitted on May 8, 2025, was preceded by a settlement agreement on April 23 being signed by Ripple’s lawyers and subsequently sanctioned by the SEC. Both had sought the approval of their agreement in accordance with the SEC v. Citigroup Global Markets Inc. standard, in which review of consent agreements is permitted.Based on precedent in the law that is quoted by the judge, this kind of relief is awarded only in “exceptional circumstances.” The motion, however, did not cite Rule 60 at all. Instead, Ripple and the SEC presented the proposal in the form of a “settlement,” missing the proper procedural avenue by mistake. That mistake was fatal.Attorney Bill Morgan clarified that the process of settlement was in motion but went off course on the fourth step, when the court dismissed their indicative ruling on account of a procedural flaw. The court specified that should they desire to proceed, the parties need to re-file according to the proper rule.How the settlement process is going1. Settlement agreement signed by Ripple parties on April 23, 2025 and by the SEC on May 8, 2025 . 2. Parties filed a motion to hold the appeal and cross appeal in abeyance 3. Parties file rule 62.1 motion asking for an indicative...— bill morgan (@Belisarius2020) May 16, 2025SEC and Ripple Still on the Same PageIn spite of the procedural hiccup, Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer, Stuart Alderoty, assured that everything remains the same with regard to the parties’ mutual intent for settlement. He stressed that the court’s decision was for how they should be submitting, but not the substance of their submission.Nothing in today’s order changes Ripple’s wins (i.e. XRP is not a security, etc). This is about procedural concerns with the dismissal of Ripple’s cross-appeal. Ripple and the SEC are fully in agreement to resolve this case and will revisit this issue with the Court, together. https://t.co/vBQdBD3FNe— Stuart Alderoty (@s_alderoty) May 15, 2025Ripple and the SEC are in it together in their quest for a resolution of the case. A re-drafted joint motion, properly supported by Rule 60, should be next. Upon being granted, it would enable the parties to go ahead with a lowered penalty and revoke the ban on sales, the last steps toward an end for this high-profile case.Related Reading | Franklin Templeton Opens Blockchain Fund with $20 Minimum Investment
You may also like

Pantera Capital Partner: The Financial Trajectory of AI Agents
AI agents will move towards fully autonomous commerce, and blockchain is the only digital-native financial track that meets its needs for identity, micropayments, and trustless execution.

In the next 5 years, Vitalik will scale Ethereum like this
Short-Term vs Long-Term, Execution, Data vs State

Sam Altman and the End of the World Capitalism
The real danger is never AI itself, but those who believe they have the right to define the human destiny.

Wall Street Rings Inflation Alarm Bells Amid Iran Tensions, What Does It Mean for Cryptocurrency?
Interest rates have remained stubbornly high, posing a challenge to the cryptocurrency bull case.

Qwen Open Source Model Enters Mobile, Nasdaq Tests Water Prediction Market, What's the Overseas Crypto Community Talking About Today?
What Was the Hottest Topic Among Expats in the Last 24 Hours?

MegaETH Co-founder: 48 Hours After Escaping Dubai, I Reassess the Entire Crypto Scene
The global environment is not favorable to us, but in the long run, it may be favorable to us.

Morning Report | Strategy increased its holdings by 3,015 bitcoins last week; BitMine increased its holdings by 50,928 ETH last week; Vitalik elaborated on the Ethereum execution layer roadmap
March 2 Market Key Events Overview

Why is it said that there are structural opportunities in encrypted AI?
When centralized AI falls into the dilemma of regulation and trust, Crypto + AI will become a structural escape route for safeguarding data and sovereignty in a multipolar world.

Make Probability an Asset: A Forward-Looking Perspective on Predictive Market Agents
The predictive market agents are expected to present early prototypes in early 2026, likely becoming an emerging product form in the field of agents in the following year.

Consumer application issues
The truly outstanding applications will not ask people to "use cryptocurrency," but will provide practical and better solutions to the problems that people already face.

Arthur Hayes: The flames of war in the Middle East rise, Bitcoin is bullish
War is often accompanied by monetary easing, which may also become an important backdrop for driving up risk assets like Bitcoin.

Legendary investor Naval: In the AI era, traditional software engineers have no value?
You can always find a perfect niche that fits you and become a leader in that field.

More absurd than knowing about the war in advance is knowing in advance about the assassination of Soleimani
The temptation of a million dollars cannot be stopped by the calamity of prison.

Key Market Insights on March 2nd, how much did you miss?
1. On-chain Funds: $96.8M Inflow to Base This Week; $234.9M Outflow from Arbitrum
2. Largest Price Swings: $SYND, $TCY
3. Top News: Anthropic Tops Global AI Product Ranking after Pentagon Rejection, Celebrities Boycott Its Competitor OpenAI

How to systematically track high-performing addresses on Polymarket?
Why can everyone see the data but not catch the "Whale Wallet"?

From Stanford Lab to Silicon Valley Streets: How OpenMind is Solving the "Last Mile" Problem of the Machine Economy?
The robotics industry is also facing issues similar to the "shanzhai era": fragmented systems, closed ecosystems, and lack of interoperability.

PlanX: Reconstructing On-Chain Execution with AI, Moving Towards a New Paradigm
Reconstructing on-chain execution with AI, moving towards a new paradigm of decentralized finance.

US Judge Allows Binance Unregistered Token Lawsuit to Advance
Key Takeaways: A federal judge in Manhattan dismissed Binance’s petition to resolve a securities lawsuit through private arbitration,…
Pantera Capital Partner: The Financial Trajectory of AI Agents
AI agents will move towards fully autonomous commerce, and blockchain is the only digital-native financial track that meets its needs for identity, micropayments, and trustless execution.
In the next 5 years, Vitalik will scale Ethereum like this
Short-Term vs Long-Term, Execution, Data vs State
Sam Altman and the End of the World Capitalism
The real danger is never AI itself, but those who believe they have the right to define the human destiny.
Wall Street Rings Inflation Alarm Bells Amid Iran Tensions, What Does It Mean for Cryptocurrency?
Interest rates have remained stubbornly high, posing a challenge to the cryptocurrency bull case.
Qwen Open Source Model Enters Mobile, Nasdaq Tests Water Prediction Market, What's the Overseas Crypto Community Talking About Today?
What Was the Hottest Topic Among Expats in the Last 24 Hours?
MegaETH Co-founder: 48 Hours After Escaping Dubai, I Reassess the Entire Crypto Scene
The global environment is not favorable to us, but in the long run, it may be favorable to us.